S5 E19 - Why Students Find Writing Persuasive Texts So Difficult

The Structured Literacy Podcast

In this episode of the Structured Literacy podcast, Jocelyn explores why students struggle with persuasive writing despite teachers implementing traditional "best practices" like modelled writing and scaffolds. Drawing on cognitive load theory, she identifies five critical mistakes: overwhelming students by modelling entire texts at once instead of breaking components down, providing written scaffolds without ensuring foundational text structure knowledge, focusing solely on text structure without explicitly teaching necessary vocabulary and syntax, failing to build sufficient background knowledge on topics, and not scaffolding the critical thinking processes required for generating and evaluating arguments.

Jocelyn emphasises that persuasive writing requires simultaneous mastery of multiple complex elements (text structure, language features, background knowledge, and argumentation skills) which can overwhelm working memory, and provides evidence-informed alternatives including explicit instruction of individual components, ensuring automaticity through repetition and retrieval, and systematic knowledge building before expecting students to think critically.

Has something in this episode resonated with you? Get in touch!

Are your students good readers, but poor spellers? If so, you are not alone. Spelling Success in Action addresses phonics, orthography, and morphology to give students a well-rounded understanding of how our language system works.
Find out how you can help your students move beyond guessing and memorisation at https://www.jocelynseamereducation.com/spelling2

Quick Links
Jocelyn Seamer Education Homepage
The Resource Room
Youtube channel
Facebook Page
#jocelynseamereducation #literacy #bestpractice #earlyprimaryyears #primaryschool #primaryschools #primaryschoolteacher #earlyyearseducation #earlyyearseducator #structuredliteracy #scienceofreading #classroom #learning #learningisfun #studentsuccess #studentsupport #teacherlife #theresourceroom #theevergreenteacher #upperprimary #upperprimaryteacher #thestructuredliteracypodcast #phoneme #grapheme #phonics #syntheticphonics

챕터

1. S5 E19 - Why Students Find Writing Persuasive Texts So Difficult (00:00:00)

2. Welcome and Persuasive Writing Introduction (00:01:53)

3. Australian Curriculum Requirements Explained (00:02:47)

4. Mistake 1: Overwhelming Cognitive Load (00:04:16)

5. Mistake 2: Overreliance on Written Scaffolds (00:07:47)

6. Mistake 3: Focusing Only on Text Structure (00:09:53)

7. Mistake 4: Neglecting Background Knowledge (00:12:31)

8. Mistake 5: Overlooking Critical Thinking (00:14:58)

9. Evidence-Based Solutions for Success (00:17:21)