Ep 391: Dialogue | Anthony Magnabosco | Shane (4) Prioritization (Linchpin to My God Belief)

The Street Epistemology Podcast

A "Pre-Methodological" Discussion Series | Part 4 of 4 Watch video of talk here: https://youtu.be/9ahfNpYbaTk Summary: After creating a pie chart of reasons for thinking his Christian worldview is objectively true into categories grouped by importance, Shane and I explore the attributes of his reasons and how they interrelate or possibly influence each other. Since all four of our talks cover important concepts that set the stage for exploring the quality of Shane's reasons and reliability of Shane's methods, I've dubbed this series "pre-method" or "pre-methodological" as a result. It's my hope that these four talks will resonate with practitioners of Street Epistemology and they can see the potential this line of questioning has when it comes to exploring deeply-held beliefs. I am hopeful a discussion like this will one day break through the noise and truly help people reconsider how they decide to interact with someone else's claims, reasons, and methods. Identifying the relationships and dependencies of our "categories of reasons" is a critical path people should routinely consider. Thanks to The Conru Foundation for supporting Street Epistemology International. Note: Despite my best efforts, I was unable to conduct a 5th chat with Shane. I realize this may frustrate some viewers, but felt it would still be valuable to release these four talks to the public. The primary purpose of my videos has always been to show others how to do Street Epistemology themselves. If Shane and I never cross paths again, it's my hope someone will continue engaging with him in a productive manner. Thank you for your understanding and time. Location: San Antonio, Texas Recorded: 4 December 2019 Released: 13 August 2020 Skip ahead to a desired point in the talk: -- Intro Montage: 00:02 Start: 01:27 Apprentices?: 01:34 Pie Chart: 02:37, 05:20, 11:09, 12:55, 18:09, 23:38, 25:47, 31:44, 51:00 Dependencies: 03:18, 25:37, 27:30 10,000 Hornets: 03:58 Justification (Why): 04:09, 05:50, 10:11, 25:03 Repeating: 04:25, 04:52, 05:45, 07:10, 07:27, 11:23, 21:53, 23:32, 24:32, 28:44, 29:57, 31:36, 37:13, 37:33, 39:37, 43:28 Clarifying: 06:40, 14:20, 15:18, 33:00 Encouraging: 07:51, 28:47 CRU Talk: 07:55 Skate or Die: 07:59, 12:46, 17:50, 21:44, 27:29, 46:55, 53:16 Summarizing: 09:55, 18:12, 23:21, 36:18 Claim (What): 10:44, 11:56 Confidence Scale: 11:00, 13:36, 21:53, 33:25 Acknowledging: 12:14, 20:45, 31:09, 37:08, 43:07 Observing: 12:31 Resetting: 12:55, 20:35, 37:09, 38:43, 40:53 Puzzle Pieces: 13:03, 56:02 Wondering: 13:18, 50:15 Bias: 15:03, 16:37, 46:46, 48:33, 49:22 Seen My Vids? 15:43, 42:53, 57:44 Steelmanning: 18:37 Think!: 19:44 Challenging: 21:23, 26:07, 27:56, 29:41, 30:32, 32:15, 33:25, 35:32, 41:33, 43:59, 44:57, 47:16 Morality: 23:03, 25:22 Assessing: 23:57, 29:05, 29:16, 31:02, 37:22 Telling: 25:22 Pausing: 26:05, 28:47, 33:20, 34:07, 38:49, 46:32, 47:53, 48:49 Reframing: 26:50 Linchpin: 34:42 Interrupting: 36:18, 40:01, 40:53, 42:01, 48:38 Afterlife: 36:26 Objectivity: 28:53, 31:46 Aporia: 29:41, 32:26, 39:02, 41:33 Storytelling: 34:13 Correcting: 43:12, 48:35, 55:31 Reminding: 43:38 Testing: 45:29, 49:00, 55:40, 56:36 Closing: 42:29, 47:11, 56:47 Commending: 45:56, 50:53, 52:24 Questions for Me: 48:07, 51:48 Planning: 51:12, 53:36, 55:15 Ego Check: 51:58 Truth Valuation: 52:35 Recapping: 56:59 End Screen: 58:02 -- Note: Add 35 seconds to these timestamps if listening to the podcast version of this talk. Audio correction provided by Philipp Grzemba. Artwork provided by Rebecca Fox http://rebeccaonpaper.com/ Intro and Outro Music 'New Horizons' by Futuremono, provided by YouTube. Mistakes: "I just don't also want to lose my point." It probably would have been more accurate to say "lose my place". Recorded w/Go-Pro. Edited w/PowerDirector. The views addressed here are mine and mine alone, and are not necessarily shared by members of my family and friends.