E462 - How To Respond When Someone Mocks the Size of Your Podcast Audience

The How To Podcast Series - Revolving Guest Co-Hosts, Podcast Tips and A Community for Podcasters

Episode 462 - How To Respond When Someone Mocks the Size of Your Podcast Audience

When someone mocks the size of your podcast audience, it is important to respond in a way that reflects confidence, encourages growth, and maintains your creative focus. Here are some ways to do that effectively for podcasters seeking creativity and engagement:

1. Emphasize Quality Over Quantity
   Remind yourself and your audience that meaningful connections matter more than raw numbers. A smaller, engaged audience can be more impactful than a large, passive one. Highlight how your content serves a niche or community, and that your goal is to create value and build long-term relationships rather than chase arbitrary metrics.

2. Share Your Growth Vision and Strategy
   Use the moment to educate about how podcast audiences grow over time with consistent work. Explain how you’re using audience insights and feedback to improve content and engagement, applying strategies like social media integration, email marketing, and collaboration to expand authentically (including analyzing listener behavior, preferences, and feedback).

3. Stay Positive and Professional
   Avoid getting defensive or argumentative. Instead, acknowledge that everyone’s podcast journey is unique and that success looks different to each creator. A positive attitude encourages respect and can lead to constructive conversations rather than conflict.

4. Highlight Engagement and Community Impact
   Mention how you track engagement metrics beyond just downloads, like who listens, how deeply they listen, and what actions they take afterward. This demonstrates that you understand your audience beyond surface stats and are focused on creating content that resonates and builds community.

5. Turn Criticism into Motivation
   Use mocking comments as fuel to improve and innovate. Consider their comments as an opportunity to gather listener feedback, test new content ideas, or refine your approach. This mindset reinforces creativity and growth, turning negativity into productive energy.

6. Educate on Podcast Audience Realities
   Explain that podcast audience metrics can be complex to interpret — download numbers don’t always equal actual listens, and audience size often grows gradually as you deepen connections. This can help others appreciate the nuance of podcast success rather than fixating on numbers alone.

7. Invite Direct Engagement
   Encourage people to listen and engage with your content directly so they can judge its value. Offering an invitation rather than confrontation can turn critics into curious listeners, or at least redirect attention to what you create.

Responding to audience size mockery with a focus on value, community, data-informed growth, and positivity enables podcasters to stay creative, authentic, and motivated without being derailed by superficial criticism. This approach builds a stronger connection with your current listeners and potentially attracts new ones who appreciate your mission and voice.

___

https://howtopodcast.ca/