"You don’t know if he’s going to hit you with a wrench or a lawsuit"

Ask the A&Ps

Should you overhaul an engine based on oil analysis? The hosts answer this question, plus fuel pumps, valve grinding, and a pesky hot cylinder.

Email [e-mail] for a chance to be on the show.

Join the world's largest aviation community at aopa.org/join

Full notes below:

David is worried about the relatively new IO-470 in his Bonanza. His oil analysis history shows a lot of aluminum, and recently, high on all metals. The narrative said to check for crankcase fretting. Paul said he would check the torque on the through bolts for piece of mind. Mike said he’s not particularly concerned about any of the numbers on the report. He said oil analysis is only a trend monitoring system. Once you establish a baseline you look for major diversions from the report. Colleen disagrees and said they aren’t stable, but have been increasing. There’s nothing that would cause all numbers to go up unless there’s dirt or a bad sample. Paul then details how David can use his borescope to look at the cam, a few lobes, lifters, and so on. It might not give him any information, but it could give him some reassurance that things are ok. Colleen suggests inspecting the pick-up screen if he can. Mike said he would never tear down an engine based on an oil report.

Maurice wants to know about the fuel pump on his Mooney M20J with a Continental IO-550. He has an altitude compensating fuel pump, and he wants to know how to use it. Mike explains that it automatically leans for you in the climb. Once he’s ready to lean in cruise, it’s time to lean manually.

Jared is ready to start grinding some valves. As he gets deeper into lapping valves in place, he’s wondering what sort of threats there are. Is it maintenance to the extent of being subjected to potential maintenance induced failures? Is it better to wait until a valve needs it, or could it be done pre-emptively? Mike said he wouldn’t necessarily do it pre-emptively, but if he sees any sort of potential deposits then it can be worth doing it. Paul said they go through an inspection process afterwards, including making sure the grinding compound is cleaned up as well as possible, that the valve keeper is properly in place, and that the bolts holding the rocker shaft holds are torqued properly. Paul said it’s critical to get another set of eyes and not check yourself. The hosts haven’t heard of any failures from lapping.

Chris has an O-540 in his Cherokee 6 that was recently overhauled. His number 6 cylinder spikes up to 450 degrees CHT on takeoff and he can’t figure out why. Mike looked at his data going back before the current engine and found that even the old engine had high temps on number 6. Chris finds that the cylinder also run the leanest. Paul suggests it could be an induction leak.