42. How to Grade Writer's Notebooks to Make it Meaningful

Annotated ELA

In this episode of Annotated ELA, Melissa tackles the often daunting task of how to grade writer's notebooks. For secondary ELA teachers who regularly integrate writing into their classrooms, assessing these notebooks can seem overwhelming. Melissa shares her approach to making this process not only manageable but also rewarding for both teachers and students. She emphasizes the importance of clear criteria and expectations, demonstrating how these can motivate students and improve their writing skills. This episode is a must-listen for anyone wanting to learn how to grade writer’s notebooks effectively.

Melissa begins by discussing the necessity of checking students' writing, while also respecting the confidentiality of their entries, with mandatory reporting as an important consideration. She offers practical suggestions for setting up writer's notebooks, such as keeping them organized and ensuring that students write thoughtfully and engage with various writing strategies. Melissa also highlights the value of using rubrics and checklists to simplify the grading process and to provide meaningful feedback that helps students grow as writers. Understanding how to grade writer’s notebooks with these tools can transform a once daunting task into a streamlined and efficient process.

Throughout the episode, Melissa provides actionable tips for creating a writing community in the classroom. She shares her methods for giving constructive feedback, managing the grading workload, and fostering a supportive environment where students feel comfortable experimenting with their writing. By the end of the episode, teachers will be equipped with strategies to make grading writer's notebooks a task they can look forward to, ultimately helping their students become more confident and skilled writers. Tune in to discover how to grade writer’s notebooks in a way that benefits both you and your students.

For additional support and resources, check out

Show notes: annotatedela.com/episode42

Follow along on Instagram @annotatedela

Engagement Tracker

Notebook Tabs - coming soon

Notebook Rubric + Checklist - coming soon

Episode 36: Writer's Notebooks: 7 Powerful Decisions for Success

Episode 38: How to Set-Up Writer’s Notebooks for Success