Player FM 앱으로 오프라인으로 전환하세요!
Why is Risk ID All Over the Map?
Manage episode 298611529 series 2951942
New website = riskcommentary.ca
Looking carefully at conventional advice, we discover why risk ID can be ineffectual.
Confusion entrained by the supposed risk ID methods set out in conventional literature.
· interviews and surveys, questionnaires
· audits, physical inspection
· brainstorming
· networking with peers, industry groups
· judgemental - speculative, conjectural, intuitive
· history, failure analysis
· examination of personal experience or past agency experience
· incident, accident and injury investigation
· scenario analysis
· decision trees
· SWOT analysis
· flow charting, system design review
· work breakdown structure
Conclusions
Procedures in this list can certainly inspire the search for risk, but are problematic for various reasons.
By contrast High Quality Risk Assessment is specified to identify uncertainty in relation to goals.
- High Quality Risk Assessment definition (Ep. 004)
- procedural grounding in proper planning (Ep. 005, 006)
- preparation of the Context Paper for the risk ID session (Ep. 007,008).
KEY QUOTE
“Such a multiplicity of [risk ID] methods might entrain confusion about the object of the exercise.” (Robertson, p.42)
LINKS
E. Robertson Solving the Enterprise Risk Management Puzzle: Secrets to Successful Implementation (2016)
20 에피소드
Manage episode 298611529 series 2951942
New website = riskcommentary.ca
Looking carefully at conventional advice, we discover why risk ID can be ineffectual.
Confusion entrained by the supposed risk ID methods set out in conventional literature.
· interviews and surveys, questionnaires
· audits, physical inspection
· brainstorming
· networking with peers, industry groups
· judgemental - speculative, conjectural, intuitive
· history, failure analysis
· examination of personal experience or past agency experience
· incident, accident and injury investigation
· scenario analysis
· decision trees
· SWOT analysis
· flow charting, system design review
· work breakdown structure
Conclusions
Procedures in this list can certainly inspire the search for risk, but are problematic for various reasons.
By contrast High Quality Risk Assessment is specified to identify uncertainty in relation to goals.
- High Quality Risk Assessment definition (Ep. 004)
- procedural grounding in proper planning (Ep. 005, 006)
- preparation of the Context Paper for the risk ID session (Ep. 007,008).
KEY QUOTE
“Such a multiplicity of [risk ID] methods might entrain confusion about the object of the exercise.” (Robertson, p.42)
LINKS
E. Robertson Solving the Enterprise Risk Management Puzzle: Secrets to Successful Implementation (2016)
20 에피소드
모든 에피소드
×플레이어 FM에 오신것을 환영합니다!
플레이어 FM은 웹에서 고품질 팟캐스트를 검색하여 지금 바로 즐길 수 있도록 합니다. 최고의 팟캐스트 앱이며 Android, iPhone 및 웹에서도 작동합니다. 장치 간 구독 동기화를 위해 가입하세요.